We've all been there—waking up tired, with a stiff back, or struggling to get comfortable night after night. At some point, it becomes clear: your mattress might be the reason you’re not sleeping well. But how do you know when it’s time to break up with your old mattress and move on to a new, supportive sleep partner? Here at City Mattress, we know that finding your perfect mattress match is essential to a well-rested, healthy life. Let’s walk through the signs that it’s time for an upgrade and introduce you to some top-rated mattress models from brands you can trust. Your new sleep oasis awaits!
When to Know It’s Time for a New Mattress
While most mattresses last 7-10 years, the need for a replacement can arise sooner if you experience the following:
- Waking Up Sore or Stiff – Consistent aches and pains could be a sign that your mattress no longer provides adequate support.
- Tossing and Turning – If you're constantly shifting at night, your mattress may not be supporting your preferred sleep position.
- Visible Wear and Tear – Sagging spots, lumps, or worn areas make it hard to find a comfortable position.
- Increased Allergies – Old mattresses accumulate dust, allergens, and even mold over time.
- You’ve Changed – Weight fluctuations, new health needs, or changes in sleep preference might mean you need a different type of mattress.
If any of these signs resonate with you, it’s probably time to start exploring new options. Let’s dive into some top-rated mattress models that offer exceptional comfort, support, and longevity.
Meet Your New Mattress Match: Our Top-Rated Models
At City Mattress, we proudly offer a curated selection of premium mattress brands, each with standout models designed for different comfort levels, sleep styles, and budgets. Here are a few customer favorites that are sure to impress:
- PranaSleep Karma Elite 2 Hybrid Super Cush
Looking for a mattress that combines superior comfort with eco-conscious materials? The PranaSleep Karma Elite Hybrid Super Cush could be the perfect choice. Known for its luxurious, supportive feel, the Karma Elite 2 Hybrid Super Cush incorporates Talalay latex for buoyant yet resilient pressure-relieving layers and pocketed coils for deep support. Handcrafted with cooling PranaCOOL technology and certified-pure foam cushioning, it’s a fantastic choice for those who prioritize USA craftsmanship with a balance of softness and support.
Why You’ll Love It:
- Crafted with naturally-derived and eco-conscious materials for healthier sleep
- Offers a plush, cushioned feel with robust support from pocketed coils
- Ideal for side sleepers or anyone seeking soft, conforming comfort
- City Mattress Celestial Callisto Plush Firm Hybrid
If you’re looking for a dependable innerspring mattress with a luxurious yet supportive feel, the City Mattress Callisto Plush Firm is an excellent choice. Made in the USA, this model features a plusher surface for comfort, with a firm, supportive core and tri-zoned coils to maintain spinal alignment. It’s perfect for those who need a balance of firmness and plushness, providing that classic innerspring feel with modern upgrades for longevity and comfort.
Why You’ll Love It:
- Combines plush comfort with firm support for all-night stability
- Built with quality materials for durability and lasting performance
- Ideal for those who prefer a traditional innerspring feel with enhanced comfort layers
- Aireloom Streamline™ Luxury Firm Innerspring
Experience the ultimate in luxurious sleep with the Aireloom Streamline Luxury Firm mattress. Handmade in the USA with Aireloom’s Patented Lift™ technology, this mattress provides an uplifting, weightless feel that contours perfectly to your body. Its premium materials and expertly designed support layers make it perfect for those who want a firm, responsive mattress with a touch of plush comfort for balanced support.
Why You’ll Love It:
- Patented Aireloom Lift™ chamber for an unparalleled sleep experience
- Luxury materials and a firm feel with just the right amount of cushion, airflow, and temperature regulation
- Handcrafted with precise attention to detail, ensuring both comfort and durability
- Beautyrest Black Series Three Medium Pillow Top Innerspring
For those seeking a blend of plush comfort and targeted support, the Beautyrest Black Series Three Medium Pillow Top is an ideal choice. With advanced cooling technology and a luxurious pillow-top surface, this mattress offers balanced support for a variety of sleep styles with latex, responsive memory foam, nano coils, and more. Its made-in-the-USA design promotes restful sleep by reducing motion transfer, making it a popular choice for couples and anyone needing consistent support with a soft, welcoming feel.
Why You’ll Love It:
- Medium pillow-top feel offers comfort without sacrificing support
- Advanced cooling technology and breathable materials for a refreshing sleep experience
- Reinforced edge support increases usable sleep surface area
- Tempur-Pedic® TEMPUR-PRObreeze° 2.0 Medium
If you’re a hot sleeper, the TEMPUR-PEDIC® TEMPUR-ProBreeze° 2.0 Medium is USA-crafted with you in mind. This model features advanced cooling technologies that work to reduce excess heat, helping you sleep up to 5 degrees cooler throughout the night. With TEMPUR® material for pressure relief and support, the ProBreeze° Medium is designed to keep you comfortably cool and supported, ideal for all types of sleepers.
Why You’ll Love It:
- Innovative cooling system that keeps you cooler all night
- TEMPUR® material adapts to your shape for personalized support
- Medium firmness balances comfort and support for most sleep positions
What to Look for in Your Mattress Upgrade
Now that you’re familiar with a few of our top-rated models, here are a few essential factors to consider as you make your selection:
- Firmness Level – Different sleep positions and body types benefit from varying firmness levels. Side sleepers usually prefer softer mattresses, while back sleepers might need something more supportive.
- Materials and Construction – Look for materials that suit your comfort preferences, whether it’s the contouring feel of memory foam, the responsiveness of an innerspring, or a hybrid of both.
- Temperature Regulation – If you tend to sleep hot, seek out models designed with cooling technologies.
- Motion Isolation – Couples should consider mattresses with strong motion isolation to minimize sleep disturbances.
Why City Mattress?
At City Mattress, we believe your mattress is more than just a place to sleep—it's an essential component of your overall well-being. We’re committed to helping you find a mattress that provides restful sleep, comfort, and support. Our selection includes only the highest quality brands, so you can trust that your investment will last.
Our team of sleep experts is here to guide you, offering personalized recommendations and insights to ensure you find your ideal match. Plus, we offer flexible financing options and a risk-free sleep trial to make the process even smoother.
Say Goodbye to Sleepless Nights
It’s time to prioritize your health, comfort, and sleep quality by finding a mattress that truly meets your needs. Whether you choose the handcrafted PranaSleep Karma Elite, the balanced City Mattress Callisto, the luxurious Aireloom Streamline™, the plush Beautyrest Black Series, or the cooling TEMPUR-ProBreeze°, City Mattress has a sleep solution for every unique need.
Ready to meet your perfect match? Visit us online or at one of our store locations today. You deserve restful nights and refreshing mornings—don’t wait to experience the difference a new mattress can make!